Offseason In Review: Toronto Blue Jays

The Blue Jays came up short on most (but not all) of their many pursuits of star free agents this winter, and the ship may have already sailed on the team’s efforts to sign Vladimir Guerrero Jr. to a contract extension. Amidst all the pessimism surrounding the Jays’ future, the team did make some notable moves to try and reload the roster after a disappointing 2024 campaign.

Major League Signings

Anthony Santander, OF: Five years, $92.5MM (includes buyout of $15MM club option for 2030; opt-out after 2027 season, but Blue Jays can void opt-out by guaranteeing 2030 option for $17.5MM salary, and adding $2.5MM to 2028 and 2029 salaries; $61.75MM of Santander’s deal is deferred)
Jeff Hoffman, RP: Three years, $33MM
Max Scherzer, SP: One year, $15.5MM
Yimi Garcia, RP: Two years, $15MM
Dillon Tate, RP: One-year split contract, $1.4MM (prorated over Tate’s time on the active roster)
Josh Walker, RP: One year split contract, $760K (prorated over Walker’s time on active roster)

2025 spending: $59MM (not counting Tate/Walker)
Total spending: $156MM

Option Decisions

Trades & Claims

Notable Minor League Signings

Extensions

Notable Losses

Toronto hitters combined for only 156 home runs and a .389 slugging percentage in 2024, so a 44-homer bat like Anthony Santander should bring some much-needed thunder to the lineup. The Blue Jays made a hefty $92.5MM investment that Santander can build on the career year that saw him hit .235/.308/.506 over 665 plate appearances for the Orioles, while handily topping his previous high of 33 homers (in 2022).

Santander’s overall hitting profile is a concern, as evidenced by the low batting average and OBP. However, Santander still posted an above-average walk rate despite the low on-base number, and his strikeout rate remained above average in 2024 even though chasing pitches has been an issue for his entire career. The switch-hitter is certainly a power-first (if not quite a power-only) type of batter, yet the profile fits for a Jays team lacking in pop and in left-handed hitting balance.

Santander will step right into the lineup as the everyday left fielder, and he’ll probably get a decent share of DH time given that his glovework is considered only passable. As defense-focused as the Blue Jays have been over the last couple of years, they continued to move in that direction with a surprising trade for arguably the sport’s best defensive second baseman.